There are albums rooted in nostalgia, and then there are albums that confront it with bruised honesty — refusing to smooth the edges or dim the ache. The Thrill Is Gone and I Can’t Get It Back, the fifth full-length release from Long Island indie-emo-punk survivors The Tin Can Collective, lives firmly in the latter category. It’s a record made by people who lived their youth recklessly and earnestly — beating hearts first, consequences later — and have emerged with memories worth retelling, even if some sting more than they shine. Recorded live in a living room with Dinos in Vietnam Productions and mixed by legendary DIY ally Jack Shirley, this album captures the raw energy of Long Island’s basement-show lineage while showcasing a band who has learned to turn the chaos of adulthood into catharsis.
The opener “Catch a Buzz” charges forward with punchy guitars and an almost cheerful desperation — a high-speed tribute to the small escapes that once felt like freedom. It’s a fitting entry point into the album’s emotional core: chasing a thrill you can’t hold onto forever. The band’s chemistry is evident immediately — John Warren’s impassioned delivery fuses with sister Jess’s riffs and Cass Kadow’s kinetic drumming, establishing a tone that feels grounded and restless. By the time track two, “Long Life, Short Stray,” arrives, the band is already nudging listeners toward the darker edges of escapism. Here, the hooks shimmer even as the lyrics admit defeat — the sound of someone who has run a long way only to find they’ve ended up exactly where the trouble started.
“Knot With Threads” slows the pace into something more reflective. It explores the frayed connections that once held a group of friends — or a version of yourself — together. What keeps the song compelling is how The Tin Can Collective translates anxiety into melody, weaving tension into the guitar lines and letting the vocals crack just enough to feel painfully real. “Friend of a Fisherman” follows with a storytelling style reminiscent of mid-2000s emo underground classics — a look at the people who drift into your orbit and leave a mark you never quite expected. By the midpoint, the title track “The Thrill Is Gone” arrives like a thesis statement: the illusions of invincibility have faded, and there’s no pretending they’ll return. But instead of mourning youth, the track honors what survived it — scars, yes, but also the ability to see clearly for the first time.
The album’s dream-logic centerpiece begins with “Three Dreams Revisited” and “Dream Weaver,” a mesmerizing duo that leans into surrealism. These songs feel like lingering in a space between night and morning — where every memory is slightly warped, and every regret swells into something cinematic. Jess’s guitars swell like waves trying to wash away what time can’t erase, while John’s voice sounds suspended between wanting to move forward and longing to go back. It’s in this section where the living-room recording choice becomes especially meaningful — the intimacy is palpable, like being inside someone else’s head while they sort through decades of emotional debris.
By the time we reach “Plans Plans Plans,” the record pivots back toward the crushing realism of adulthood. It’s a song about the suddenly small-feeling dreams once shouted from rooftops. The energy is tense and explosive — a recognition that life doesn’t wait for you to figure out where you’re going. Then comes “Trouble,” the track that most directly names the theme Warren has lived and shared: rebellion feels glamorous until the real danger arrives. His vocals are heavy with lived experience, and Pete Cianciatto’s guitar feels like a co-author in the storytelling. When the chorus erupts — “eventually, the imagined danger I romanticized started to become real” — you don’t hear regret so much as clarity. It’s a song that says: it wasn’t all worth it, but it wasn’t nothing, either.
“Wake Up Forever” shifts gears again with a sense of reluctant hope. There’s beauty in the exhaustion — a slow realization that life after the thrill doesn’t have to be cruel, just different. “Good News Bad News” leans further into that truth, accepting that adulthood is a constant negotiation between tiny victories and lasting disappointments. There’s a bittersweet humor in the delivery, like a band who has finally learned how to laugh at the universe’s uneven dealing of cards. The finale “Sleepwalk” ties the record together with grace — a lullaby for people still restless. Its quiet intensity mirrors the album’s emotional arc: no longer sprinting toward thrills, but walking forward anyway, even if the path feels foggy.
Across its twelve tracks, The Thrill Is Gone and I Can’t Get It Back is a reckoning. The Tin Can Collective doesn’t embellish or romanticize the hardest parts of their past, but deliver them with cracked-paint authenticity and an unwavering pulse. What began in 2011 as a home-recording project has become a resilient musical family — and you can hear that bond in every sweaty shout-along chorus and every soft breath before an emotional plunge. This album is the sound of growing up without letting go of the people who helped you survive the process.
The title may suggest that something important has been lost — but what this record reveals is everything that’s been gained. The thrill may never return in its wildest form, but something sturdier has taken its place: truth, perspective, and a connection that outlasts late-night chaos. The Tin Can Collective has captured Long Island’s DIY heart at full volume — bruised, wiser, and still ready to swing
For more information, follow The Tin Can Collective:
Website – Facebook – Spotify – Bandcamp – Instagram
